Past Wisconsin OYF Runners Up
Starting in 2012 National allowed states to send top two candidates
| Year | Name | Runner Up | City |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1992 | John & Susan Van Gheem | 1st Runner - Up | DePere |
| Dennis & Joan Genke | 2nd Runner - Up | Cecil | |
| David & Adele Huser | 3rd Runner - Up | Vesper | |
| Larry & Elise Shambeau | 4th Runner - Up | Two Rivers | |
| 1993 | Hank & Pam Wagner | 1st Runner - Up | Oconto Falls |
| Roland & Ginny Peterson | 2nd Runner - Up | Blue Mounds | |
| Doug & Mary Urban | 3rd Runner - Up | Milladore | |
| Jerry & Peggy Miesler | 4th Runner - Up | Luxemburg | |
| 1994 | Dale & Cheryl Wagner | 1st Runner - Up | Manitowoc |
| Merlin & Peppy Rohm | 2nd Runner - Up | Kaukauna | |
| Joseph & Diane Thome | 3rd Runner - Up | Fond du Lac | |
| Andreas & Susan Heer | 4th Runner - Up | Rice Lake | |
| 1995 | James & Kelly Rickert | 1st Runner - Up | Eldorado |
| Duane Schultz & Heidi Schultz | 2nd Runner - Up | Waterloo | |
| Jeff & Connie Horsens | 3rd Runner - Up | Cecil | |
| Donald & Dorothy Harms | 4th Runner - Up | Reedsburg | |
| 1996 | Brian & Chris Costello | 1st Runner - Up | Fond du Lac |
| Ken & Crystal Verhasselt | 2nd Runner - Up | Kaukauna | |
| Bruce & Rose Gulcynski | 3rd Runner - Up | Thorp | |
| Randy & Maribeth Mahr | 4th Runner - Up | Stanley | |
| 1997 | Jerry & Linda White | 1st Runner - Up | Reedsburg |
| Scott Pralle & Pam Selz-Pralle | 2nd Runner - Up | Humbird | |
| Matt Lippert & Martha Lippert | 3rd Runner - Up | Pittsville | |
| Donald & Mary Jo Winter | 4th Runner - Up | Loyal | |
| 1998 | Richard & Lisa Geske | 1st Runner - Up | Galesville |
| Virgil & Dawn Haag | 2nd Runner - Up | Mt. Horeb | |
| Steve Schluter & Deb Schluter | 3rd Runner - Up | Johnson Creek - Watertown | |
| Terry & Christine Van Hoof | 4th Runner - Up | Kaukauna | |
| 1999 | Steve & Heidi Smits | 1st Runner - Up | Markesan |
| Robert & Lisa Condon | 2nd Runner - Up | Horicon | |
| Jerry & Julie Ambrosius | 3rd Runner - Up | Seymour | |
| Dennis & Virginia Hatfield | 4th Runner - Up | Viola | |
| 2000 | Randy & Marilyn Julka | 1st Runner - Up | Rosendale |
| Wayne & Bonnie Jones | 2nd Runner - Up | Mt. Horeb | |
| Bart & Jody Kasten | 3rd Runner - Up | Reedsville | |
| Mike & Connie Maass | 4th Runner - Up | Seymour | |
| 2001 | Steven & Debra Abel | 1st Runner - Up | Fond du Lac |
| Jeff & Holly Schmidt | 2nd Runner - Up | Gresham | |
| Randy Roecker & Ruth Roecker | 3rd Runner - Up | Loganville | |
| Mitch & Holly Lindner | 4th Runner - Up | Loyal | |
| 2002 | Kevin & Christine Griswold | 1st Runner - Up | Ixonia |
| Brad & Lorie Brunner | 2nd Runner - Up | Cecil | |
| Troy & Sandra Madland | 3rd Runner - Up | Lyndon Station | |
| 2003 - New Glarus | Kelly & Brian Goehring | 1st Runner - Up | Newton |
| Dan & Shelly Truttman | 2nd Runner - Up | Blanchardville | |
| Todd & Tricia Hoesly | 3rd Runner - Up | Brodhead | |
| John & Kim Koepke | 4th Runner - Up | Oconomowoc | |
| 2004 - Eau Claire | Paul & Shelly Schweiger | 1st Runner - Up | Viola |
| Dan & Catherine Kleiber | 2nd Runner - Up | Waterloo | |
| Brian Kindschi | 3rd Runner - Up | Prairie du Sac | |
| Doug & Christina Rebout | 4th Runner - Up | Janesville | |
| 2005 - Eau Claire | David & Jacqueline Meinert | 1st Runner - Up | St. Cloud |
| Jason & Robin Untz | 2nd Runner - Up | Lake Mills | |
| Michael Bodart | 3rd Runner - Up | Pulaski | |
| Peter & Christina Winch | 4th Runner - Up | Fennimore | |
| 2006 - Green Bay | Joseph (III) & Christy Tomandl | 1st Runner - Up | Medford |
| 2007 - Richland Center | Dennis & Suzanne Roehl | 1st Runner - Up | Loyal |
| Bill & Bridget Cioloksz | 2nd Runner - Up | Thorp | |
| James & Tammy Fahey | 3rd Runner - Up | Edgar | |
| Rob & Denise Sebranek | 4th Runner - Up | Lone Rock | |
| 2008 - Shawano | Chad Neeser | 1st Runner - Up | Rice Lake |
| Mark & Rachel Parker | 2nd Runner - Up | Viola | |
| Keith & Fay Niemann | 3rd Runner - Up | Edgar | |
| Wade & Diane Shaw | 4th Runner - Up | Baraboo | |
| 2009 - Eau Claire | Matt & Heather Schmitz | 1st Runner - Up | Richland Center |
| Kat Becker & Tony Schultz | 2nd Runner - Up | Athens | |
| Gary & Kimberly Nolden | 3rd Runner - Up | Prairie du Sac | |
| 2010 - Mishicot | Heather & Jay Jauquet | 1st Runner - Up | Pulaski |
| Jamie & Amy Larson | 2nd Runner - Up | Evansville | |
| 2011 - Eau Claire | Ryan & Sarah Radecki | 1st Runner - Up | Pulaski |
| Ben & Nicki Peterson | 2nd Runner - Up | Grantsburg | |
| Tim & Shana Johnson | 3rd Runner - Up | Baraboo | |
| Bruce & Jolene Gumz | 4th Runner - Up | Dorchester | |
| Scot & Jennifer Zimmerman | 5th Runner - Up | Osseo | |
| 2012 - Marshfield | Brian & Stephanie Perkins | 1st Runner - Up | Richland Center |
| Laura Daniels & Jarred Searls | 2nd Runner - Up | Cobb | |
| Ryan & Cheri Klussendorf | 3rd Runner - Up | Medford | |
| Sander & Amy Penterman | 4th Runner - Up | Thorp | |
| 2013 - Keshena | Brian & Nicole Barlass | 1st Runner - Up | Janesville |
| Matt & Tabitha Hartwig | 2nd Runner - Up | Athens | |
| Kurt & Diana Strassburg | 3rd Runner - Up | Bowler | |
| John & Deb Ihm | 4th Runner - Up | Lancaster | |
| 2014 - Green Bay | Jim & Shelly Grosenick | 1st Runner - Up | Watertown |
| Christopher Davis | 2nd Runner - Up | Wisconsin Dells | |
| 2015 - Weston | Craig & Nicole Schmidt | 1st Runner - Up | Juneau |
| Amy Raboine | 2nd Runner - Up | Reedsburg | |
| 2016 - Eau Claire | Daniel & Sarah Diederich | 1st Runner - Up | Hobart |
| Ryan & Katie Richert | 2nd Runner - Up | Lyndon Station | |
| 2017 - Baraboo | Amy Raboine & Marques Koenig | 1st Runner - Up | Reedsburg |
| 2018 - Watertown | Justin & Darci Daniels | 1st Runner - Up | Hixton |
| 2019 - Johnson Creek | Brody & Carolyn Stapel | 1st Runner - Up | Cedar Grove |
| Scott Laeser & Chelsea Chandler | 2nd Runner - Up | Argyle | |
| 2020 - Chippewa Falls | Katy Schultz | 1st Runner - Up | Fox Lake |
| Jeremy & Heather Natzke | 2nd Runner - Up | Greenleaf | |
| 2021 - Neenah | Joe & Ashley Dudkiewicz National Winner |
1st Runner - Up | Crivitz |
| 2022 - Neenah | Mike & Gina Redetzke | 1st Runner - Up | Colby |
| 2023 - Manitowoc | Brody & Carolyn Stapel | 1st Runner - Up | Cedar Grove |
| Mark & Vanna Leichtfuss | 2nd Runner - Up | Two Rivers | |